The $1,000 Spy Scrapbook

FASCINATING AND VALUABLE ARE TWO DIFFERENT THINGS

Katrina and I got into this business because we love research. As a child, I wanted to be a history teacher when others wanted to be firemen. I wanted to explain what happened in 1812. Imagine how this contributed to my popularity.

Things still come across our desks that just need to be bought. Not because they’re valuable but because we just want to know what happens next. Last week a lady bought a storage compartment with a HUGE scrapbook 8 inches thick with hundreds of pages, weighing 15 pounds. We passed. She was persistent.

Inside was the history of Evelyn Valentini, a U.S. Army officer whose papers included military intelligence work, wartime service and WWI activity in Europe. There were hundreds of calling cards, photos, letters and maps. Among them were references to confidential missions and an “observation” of national elections inside Cuba. Carefully worded communications to Washington made you read between the lines. Someone had brought me a real-life spy novel. Sadly, it weighed 50 times more than a paperback and belonged to someone who wanted money for it.

Cover of E.E. Valentini military scrapbook with U.S. Army eagle insignia and rank panels from 1917 to 1925

Valuable and fascinating are two different things. A distinction I understand well is that finding a buyer for an obscure spy’s photo book is difficult, as is the calling card of men whose importance depended on no one knowing what they did. Our $200 offer was declined because she thought the maps had value.

I began doing the fake arithmetic that occurs when a collector pretends to be a businessman. Would the maps cover the purchase? Perhaps I could read everything first! I paid $1,000. There’s no waiting list for obscure spies’ business cards, but the maps may help us break even. That’s my current “business plan” and Katrina treated it respectfully.

But I’ve spent hours following Valentini’s assignments and deciphering his delicate reports to Washington. There is a particular pleasure in reading papers someone saved without knowing that a century later a stranger would be completely absorbed. We will sell the maps. But if you ask whether I’ve gotten my $1,000 worth, only the history teacher in me has already said yes.

While this will take months to read, the interactions and detailed conversations within government agencies is mesmerizing. While we may lose money, we gained a lot of knowledge and great pleasure.

Share This Article
Continue reading
Never miss an article
Skip to content